社区黑料

As President Donald Trump has ramped up deportations, some immigrant students across New York have been too afraid to attend class in person. In response, some school districts have turned to virtual learning, a move the state鈥檚 Education Department is sanctioning, officials revealed last week.

鈥淚 will tell you in the sense of a crisis, we do have some districts right now 鈥� that are taking advantage and providing virtual instruction to our children who are afraid to go to school,鈥� Associate Education Commissioner Elisa Alvarez .

Alvarez shared with the board a the state Education Department issued in March clarifying that districts have the flexibility to offer online instruction to 鈥渟tudents who may be unable or averse to attending school, including during times of political uncertainty.鈥�

The memo further specified schools can tap online learning for immigrant and migrant students 鈥渨ho may be affected and reluctant to attend school in person due to concerns about their personal safety and security.鈥�

Alvarez didn鈥檛 disclose how many or which districts were using the approach and for how many students. A state Education Department spokesperson did not respond to follow-up questions.

New York City public schools already have virtual options available and aren鈥檛 doing anything different for immigrant students fearful of attending school, a spokesperson for the city鈥檚 Education Department said.

Still, the disclosure from state officials highlights the ongoing fears some immigrant students are facing four months into the Trump administration and raises fresh questions about how their school experiences are being affected.

Shortly after taking office, Trump barring federal immigration agents from making arrests at 鈥渟ensitive locations鈥� including schools.

Migrant families staying in New York City shelters expressed acute fears during the week after Trump鈥檚 inauguration in January and , likely contributing to lower citywide attendance rates that week (though Mayor Eric Adams later ). Some city educators said they鈥檝e seen attendance for immigrant students rebound since that first week.

City policy prohibits federal law enforcement agents, including Immigration and Customs Enforcement, from entering schools without a warrant signed by a judge, and Education Department officials have for how to respond.

At the state level, the Attorney General鈥檚 office and Education Department issued in March reiterating that state and federal law both compel districts to only permit federal law enforcement to enter schools under very limited circumstances.

Many school leaders have worked hard to communicate those policies and reassure anxious families. And immigration enforcement inside of schools has remained rare.

But some high-profile raids have targeted school-age children, including one in the upstate New York hometown of Trump border czar Tom Homan that swept up three students in the local public schools, . And there have been across the of parents detained by immigration agents right outside schools during drop-off time.

Under those circumstances, virtual learning could give schools a way to keep up some connection with students or families who might otherwise completely disengage.

But some New York City educators said they鈥檙e still working hard to convince fearful immigrant students to come to school in person, noting that virtual learning was especially during the COVID pandemic.

Lara Evangelista, the executive director of the Internationals Network, which oversees 17 public schools in the five boroughs catering exclusively to newly arrived immigrant students, said none of her schools have made the 鈥減urposeful choice鈥� to engage fearful students through virtual learning.

鈥淰irtual learning for [English Learners] was really challenging during COVID,鈥� she said.

Alan Cheng, the superintendent who oversees the international schools as well as the city鈥檚 dedicated virtual schools, said he hasn鈥檛 seen any significant changes in enrollment or interest in online learning due to fear of in-person attendance among immigrant students.

And while virtual learning might be able to offer a version of the academic experience of in-person school, it鈥檚 harder for it to replicate some of the other services that schools provide families.

鈥淥ur schools serve much more than just the academic environment,鈥� Cheng said. 鈥淭hey are really community schools, they provide health care, they provide plenty of other resources.鈥�

This story was originally published by Chalkbeat. Chalkbeat is a nonprofit news site covering educational change in public schools. Sign up for their newsletters at .

Did you use this article in your work?

We鈥檇 love to hear how 社区黑料鈥檚 reporting is helping educators, researchers, and policymakers.