鈥淲e’re asking you to take a pledge today,鈥� he said during the May 20 Zoom session, providing a link for participants to sign. Other elements of Thurmond鈥檚 agenda include for 100,000 children, free access for families to ebooks and a campaign to deliver to children鈥檚 homes.

The event followed the work of a literacy task force Thurmond created last fall. But the superintendent, who is running for reelection, was clear that as long as he鈥檚 in charge, California won鈥檛 follow the lead of other states 鈥� adopting a statewide literacy policy that prioritizes phonics, the connections between letter sounds and written words.

鈥淲e are not promoting a one-size-fits-all approach in California,鈥� he said. 鈥淭hat’s been tried before. Our state is too large, is too diverse.鈥� 

Critics dismissed Thurmond鈥檚 plan to combat what they describe as a literacy crisis in the nation鈥檚 most populous state. 

District leaders, advocates and some lawmakers want all schools to screen for dyslexia, a learning disability, and adopt phonics-based instruction. While Mayor Eric Adams has mandated a phonics-based curriculum and Michigan lawmakers are that would require dyslexia screening, California, some argue, passed up an opportunity to address long-standing achievement gaps in children鈥檚 reading.

Overall, 37 percent of the state鈥檚 fourth-graders score below the basic level on . The average score for Hispanic students is 27 points below that of white students, and the gap between Black and white students is even larger.

鈥淲e keep applying patchwork solutions to a system that never worked,鈥� said Todd Collins, a school board member of the Palo Alto Unified School District in Silicon Valley. He鈥檚 also an organizer of the , which last year issued a 鈥渞eport card鈥� ranking districts on the percentage of high-need Hispanic students proficient in reading by third grade. 鈥淟ibrary cards and e-books are not going to fix a system that doesn’t teach kids right in the first place.鈥�

Some members of Thurmond鈥檚 literacy agree. Kareem Weaver, part of the Oakland NAACP鈥檚 education committee and leader of a nonprofit focusing on literacy, said the group produced 鈥渁 grab bag鈥� of solutions. 

But they 鈥渄idn鈥檛 get to the root cause of why kids aren鈥檛 reading,鈥� he said. 鈥淲e鈥檙e not explicitly teaching them how to read and crack the code.鈥�

Thurmond isn鈥檛 opposed to districts adopting phonics-based instruction but instead emphasized that because of relief funds and a budget surplus 鈥淐alifornia has more resources than we鈥檝e ever seen鈥� to provide teacher training and increase the number of reading specialists in schools. passed last year requires new teachers entering the field to know how to teach 鈥渇oundational reading skills,鈥� but the state isn鈥檛 pushing districts to adopt a specific curriculum.

During Thurmond鈥檚 online event, only Tyrone Howard, an education professor at the University of California Los Angeles and president-elect of the American Educational Research Association, emphasized phonics. 

鈥淚’m old school,鈥� he said. 鈥淭he data shows that phonics instruction can go a long way in helping kids to develop the fundamentals around reading.鈥�

Roughly 20 states have adopted so-called based on decades of that emphasize phonics, fluency and vocabulary development as the foundations of learning how to read. Some experts who previously embraced strategies that encouraged children to depend on pictures and familiar words to read ones they don鈥檛 know have since changed their views. Once an exemplar of this approach, Lucy Calkins updated her curriculum based on the research, according to a recent article that generated a . 

The question in California is whether a commitment is enough.

鈥淲e鈥檝e been committing since 鈥楢 Nation at Risk鈥� and we haven鈥檛 gotten there yet,鈥� said Barbara Nemko, superintendent of the Napa County Office of Education, referring to the landmark 1983 report that inspired education reform efforts. One of Thurmond鈥檚 task force co-chairs, she added that if the label has become divisive, 鈥渢hen call it something else.鈥�

Policymakers and education groups in the state are also divided over dyslexia screening, even though over 30 states already have such laws in place. 

Thurmond promised to make a currently in development at the University of California San Francisco available to schools once it鈥檚 ready, possibly by the 2023-24 school year. But the California Teachers Association opposes that was introduced last year and never received a hearing. They said mandated screening 鈥渓essens the instructional time available for learning the required curriculum.鈥� The California School Boards Association also opposes it.

Reading Recovery and Mississippi

Thurmond isn鈥檛 the only state leader whose response to what some have called a has come under fire. Some question the support of researcher and state board Chair Linda Darling-Hammond for Reading Recovery, a long-running tutoring program for first graders offered in about . In a , on pandemic recovery and a recent literacy task force , Darling-Hammond linked the program to successful schools. 

A , presented at a research conference, found that children who participated in the program scored lower on state tests in third and fourth grade than those who didn鈥檛 participate. Her comments, said Collins from Palo Alto, show 鈥渨e have a dated and misguided understanding of what works.鈥�

But Darling-Hammond, who also led President Joe Biden鈥檚 education transition team and recommended Miguel Cardona to be U.S. education secretary, told 社区黑料 that her statements about the program have never been in the 鈥渃ontext of an endorsement鈥� and noted that Reading Recovery is listed in the U.S. Department of Education鈥檚 鈥渃learinghouse鈥� of . 

She underscored the limitations of the study, including the fact that the researchers collected follow-up results from just a quarter of the third graders and 16% of fourth graders who were part of the original sample. She noted that a on Reading Recovery, presented at the same conference, found positive results for students in England through age 16.

鈥淚 think different interventions work well for different students,鈥� Darling-Hammond said 鈥淚 hope we won’t get wrapped up in a silver bullet idea about any intervention.鈥� 

She said California fourth graders鈥� reading scores have inched closer to the since 2013 and highlighted the state鈥檚 plan this year to spend $500 billion on literacy initiatives, including reading coaches and specialists. Those positions are necessary, she said, because the state hires too many teachers without full credentials.

鈥淚n the schools with the greatest needs, you might have half or more of the teachers without any training to teach reading,鈥� she said.

She also pointed to gains in , which in 2019, made more progress in reading than any other state. But she said people often 鈥渟implify鈥� the state鈥檚 approach by only highlighting teacher training in phonics-based instruction.

鈥淚t’s a very robust program,鈥� she said. 鈥淧honics is very important. Phonemic awareness is very important, but that is not all they do.鈥� 

鈥楢n equity issue鈥�

With the state taking what Darling-Hammond called a more 鈥渄ecentralized鈥� direction than Mississippi, some school and district leaders have moved on their own to revamp the way they teach children to read. 

In 2019, when Lilia Espinoza took over as principal of Hardin Elementary in Hollister, California, she found staff members who worked hard on student reading with little to show for it.

鈥淗istorically, this school has struggled to really pump out students who are on grade level,鈥� she said. With a high English learner population 鈥� as is the case in many California schools 鈥� she said teachers thought if children couldn鈥檛 read a word, they just didn鈥檛 understand the vocabulary instead of not being able to sound it out.

She reached out to , a private school in Seaside, California, that offered training in structured literacy and using practices that have worked with struggling readers. 

Hardin teachers and reading specialists now devote 45 minutes to an hour each day to explicit phonics lessons as part of a larger English language arts curriculum. Children can get 鈥渁ntsy鈥� during that time, Espinoza said. But despite remote learning, the number of students referred to special education has dropped from 21 in 2017-19 to three this year. She thinks the gains would have been stronger if it hadn鈥檛 been for the pandemic.

Now, she worries that other 鈥渂udget issues鈥� will lead the district to cut funding for reading intervention teachers. She started with four, is now down to two, and might only have one next year. She wrote a letter to state leaders asking for more specialists.

鈥淚t鈥檚 an equity issue,鈥� she said. 鈥淣ot being able to secure support for early literacy for all students is not OK.鈥�

When Education Secretary Miguel Cardona toured South Bend, Indiana鈥檚 Madison STEAM Academy in September, he made a quick impression on the district鈥檚 superintendent, C. Todd Cummings. 

Cummings remembers the secretary鈥檚 interest in COVID protocols, the facility鈥檚 STEM makerspace, and that he spoke Spanish to students at the bilingual school. By the time the visit ended, he came away feeling like he could pick up the phone and call Cardona if needed. 

鈥淗e鈥檚 done a lot to make the department more approachable,鈥� Cummings said. 鈥淗e understands running a district, but he also understands teachers in the classroom.鈥�

Having one of their own helming the U.S. Department of Education has gone a long way toward mending the fractured relationship between district leaders and the agency that existed under Cardona鈥檚 predecessor. Betsy DeVos was the consummate outsider. She warred with unions, made comments that many teachers found , and attempted to direct relief funds meant for the public system to private schools. In contrast, when the former Connecticut state chief meets with superintendents and school leaders, 鈥渉e鈥檚 talking shop鈥� on everything from bell schedules to graduation rates, said Ronn Nozoe, head of the National Association of Secondary School Principals.

But almost a year into Cardona鈥檚 tenure, and with the pandemic showing no signs of abating, his department has sometimes struggled to keep up. COVID-19 has thrust the agency into the public eye almost as much as the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, and, like the CDC, it has often come under fire for being slow to respond to a fast-changing virus. To some, Cardona鈥檚 camaraderie with educators helps explain why he has sometimes appeared reluctant to embrace another constituency, whose power and visibility has grown with the pandemic: parents. 

Sarah Carpenter, executive director of The Memphis Lift, a nonprofit that trains parents to advocate for their children鈥檚 educational needs, said she hasn鈥檛 forgotten that parent leaders weren鈥檛 asked to speak at Cardona鈥檚 first virtual summit on reopening almost a year ago. 

鈥淭hey know we鈥檙e here, and we鈥檙e just not accounted for,鈥� she said, adding that parents 鈥渋n those communities where this pandemic hit the hardest鈥� should have had a voice. A June event focusing on equity didn鈥檛 feature parents either.

Cardona hasn鈥檛 ignored parents, and often reminds the public that his two teenage children, still attending public school in Meriden, Connecticut, have endured their own disruptions in learning. His first act as secretary was to write to parents and students acknowledging the hardships caused by the pandemic, and he has urged schools to rebuild trust with families.

More recently, when schools began to shift to remote learning because of the Omicron variant, Cardona told 社区黑料, 鈥淥ur parents have done enough.鈥� That same week, the announcement of another round of grants to state came with Cardona鈥檚 statement that, 鈥淢eaningful parent engagement 鈥� has never been more important.鈥�

But observers say his messages tend to emphasize over student recovery. When the department last month to use federal relief funds for teacher pay raises and hiring bonuses, Marguerite Roza, director of Georgetown University鈥檚 Edunomics Lab, said 鈥渢he balance feels a little off.鈥�

The pandemic has mobilized many parents to take a more central role in their children鈥檚 education, and their frustration over extended school closures likely tipped the Virginia governor鈥檚 race in favor of Republican Glenn Youngkin. 

Keri Rodrigues, president of the National Parents Union, has tried to drive that point home. She regularly participates in 鈥渟takeholder鈥� meetings with the department, and shares monthly parent survey data with Christian Rhodes, chief of staff for the department鈥檚 Office of Elementary and Secondary Education. But she described the department鈥檚 parent engagement efforts as a 鈥渂ox-checking exercise.鈥�

鈥淭hat鈥檚 not what this moment calls for. It calls for listening to people’s pain,鈥� she said. 鈥淧arents expect to be engaged on a whole new level because we had to hold it down for [schools] while they weren鈥檛 there.鈥�

鈥楴ot a slow-moving moment鈥�

Leaders in education said Cardona has shown skill in managing the mountain of challenges he faced when he entered the job: more than half of schools still not fully open, expectations that he quickly reverse the previous administration鈥檚 stance on students鈥� civil rights, and low morale among what Nozoe called the department鈥檚 鈥渂eat-down career staff.鈥� Cardona, he added, is trying to rebuild an agency that DeVos shouldn鈥檛 even exist.

Cardona said his top priority has been helping schools reopen and stay that way. Others credit him with steering billions in federal aid to states and districts on a short timeline.

鈥淭hey’ve made a huge amount of progress in a very, very difficult time,鈥� said Linda Darling-Hammond, president of the California State Board of Education and president and CEO of the Learning Policy Institute, a think tank. She led President Joe Biden鈥檚 transition team for education and as the nominee.

She specifically noted his team鈥檚 work to get the American Rescue Plan funding for schools 鈥渙ut the door with guidance and support for how to spend it鈥� and early efforts to make the CDC鈥檚 鈥渨onky and mysterious鈥� school reopening guidelines more accessible to educators. Recent confusion over whether the agency鈥檚 updated quarantine guidance applied to schools, however, drew fresh .

Some noted that communication from the department often hasn鈥檛 matched the urgency state and district leaders have experienced during the pandemic. 

In November, the department said it was OK to use relief funds to pay for alternate forms of for students in the face of a bus driver shortage. But that was a month after New York , a Democrat, asked for the guidance, and two months after Massachusetts Gov. Charlie Baker called in the to drive students to school. 

In mid-December, the department issued a on jumpstarting school accountability systems, but state officials started calling for that in September. 

鈥淭hey are slow moving,鈥� said Roza, 鈥渁nd it鈥檚 not a slow-moving moment in public education.鈥�

In an interview with 社区黑料, Cardona said the department responds with guidance when 鈥渨e hear from the field.鈥� He noted the staff鈥檚 efforts to host multiple webinars and respond to questions from educators, but acknowledged that guidance from the department has sometimes lagged. He vowed to do better. 鈥淲e have to stay ahead of things, and we鈥檙e going to continue to improve communications.鈥�

鈥楳ore influence鈥�

As he nears his first year as a cabinet member, Cardona reflected on what the department has accomplished under his leadership. 

While Omicron has led to short-term closures of as many as 5,400 schools, according to a frequently updated , Cardona noted that in-person learning had hit of schools by early December. And he takes pride that the department is addressing problems with Public Service Loan Forgiveness 鈥� a federal program meant to encourage students to go into nonprofit and public sector jobs, like teaching, in exchange for debt relief. Under DeVos, the department denied most requests for relief, and borrowers complained that loan servicers gave on how to meet the program鈥檚 strict criteria. The department鈥檚 management of the program prompted the American Federation of Teachers . Since Cardona started, the department has wiped out roughly $12.7 billion in college debt, including almost $2 billion for the public service program.

鈥淣ot only are we providing some loan forgiveness, but we’re fixing the systems that led to the problems that we have now,鈥� he said, adding that he wants to continue to 鈥渕ake higher education more accessible to more students without having to be tethered in debt for the rest of their lives.鈥�

Before Cardona was confirmed, there was speculation he鈥檇 be overshadowed by Biden鈥檚 White House advisers, who included two former high-level education officials from the Obama administration. More recently, Rodrigues quipped that , president of the National Education Association, likely has more pull with the administration than Cardona.

Conservative pundits have sized him up as Rick Hess, director of Education Policy Studies at the American Enterprise Institute, described him as 鈥渦nder-the-radar, except when he鈥檚 been waving the flag for partisan administration objectives.鈥�

But those who support those objectives say Cardona has clout with the president. 

鈥淚 think with every passing day, he has more and more influence with the White House,鈥� said American Federation of Teachers President Randi Weingarten, who first met Cardona when he was a teacher and now has a friendly competition with him over who has visited more states and schools over the past year. By late December, she鈥檇 hit 28 states; he鈥檇 made it to 25.

She said he advocated with the White House for changes to the loan forgiveness program and for putting teachers second in line to receive the first wave of COVID-19 vaccines, after health care workers.

Interestingly, given the coziness many of his critics assume Cardona enjoys with the unions, he has had trouble with the one representing employees in his own department. 

鈥楾he huge political divide鈥�

In early December, the Federal Labor Relations Authority found the department guilty of 14 violations of labor law 鈥� actions that date back to 2018 when the employee union鈥檚 collective bargaining rights. A of federal employees showed that morale within the department had declined far more than in any other agency. Those grievances have continued under Cardona, according to Cathie McQuiston, deputy general counsel with the American Federation of Government Employees.

The complaints involve inconsistent policies for working remotely, employee evaluation procedures and denying staff union representation when they have a dispute.

Under DeVos, the department was 鈥減araded out as an example to other agencies of the kinds of things they should be doing in the Trump administration,鈥� McQuiston said. 鈥淭here has to be a political will to come in and say, 鈥榃e鈥檙e not doing that anymore.鈥� At education, we struggle to get that commitment.鈥�

According to a department spokesperson, efforts to resolve the complaints are ongoing and the agency is 鈥渃ommitted to making sure it is a great place to work.鈥� Both sides are scheduled to meet Thursday.

While addressing internal issues, Cardona was hit with a summer storm of public controversy over mask mandates and school equity initiatives. Superintendents were targeted with death threats, brawls broke out at school board meetings and school leaders tried to make sense of contradictory court rulings and mandates over masks.

鈥淚 wonder whether he anticipated the huge political divide over masks or no masks,鈥� said Deborah Delisle, who served as assistant secretary of elementary and secondary education in the Obama administration and is now president and CEO of ALL4Ed, a nonprofit education policy organization. 

In August, Cardona departed from his usual cordial tone to take a against states banning local districts from mandating masks. 

鈥淒on鈥檛 be the reason why schools are interrupted,鈥� he said at a , indirectly challenging the governors of Florida and Texas.

But unless Republicans pressed him during Congressional hearings, he avoided the fray over critical race theory 鈥� a legal argument that racism lies at the core of U.S. institutions to intentionally advantage white people 鈥� and even to the controversial 1619 Project and the work of author Ibram X. Kendi from a civics grant program.

鈥淲e don鈥檛 get involved in curriculum issues,鈥� he said during a June budget hearing, but stressed his support for culturally relevant teaching. 鈥淲hen students see themselves in the curriculum, they are more likely to be engaged.鈥�

Some observers suggest he could have done more. 

Hess, at the American Enterprise Institute, said Cardona could 鈥減erhaps carve out room for the serious center鈥� by defending 鈥渁 progressive vision鈥� but denouncing some of the examples that critics have found so , such as asking students to label themselves as 鈥渙ppressed鈥� or 鈥渙ppressor.鈥�

But Julia Martin, legislative director at Brustein and Manasevit, a law firm specializing in education, said there was no political upside for Cardona to wade any deeper into those waters.

鈥淭hese issues, by their nature, are local issues,鈥� she said. 鈥淭here’s no way in many of these instances to come out and make a principled statement that doesn鈥檛 bother some people.鈥�

The typically controversy-averse Cardona is a departure from the activist chiefs who have occupied the department since the No Child Left Behind era. Unlike many of his predecessors, Cardona doesn鈥檛 have a presidential mandate to implement bold reforms. 

鈥淲e’re still in a crisis, versus coming out of a crisis back in 2009,鈥� said John Bailey, a senior fellow at AEI. That鈥檚 when Arne Duncan became secretary under President Obama, with a far-reaching mission to incentivize states to embrace controversial reforms such as overhauling teacher evaluations and adopting Common Core standards.

Even if Cardona had such a mandate, Bailey said, the pandemic leaves him in the position of trying to provide a 鈥渞apid response during an unfolding crisis that continues to play out.鈥�

If the pandemic doesn鈥檛 continue to steal most of Cardona鈥檚 focus, he said he hopes to shift attention in 2022 toward issues a little closer to his heart: 鈥渢eaching and learning.鈥�

As someone who attended a technical high school in his hometown of Meriden, Cardona wants to see 鈥渂etter pathways鈥� for students to two- and four-year schools and the workforce, especially with the jobs that will be created as a result of the $1.2 trillion federal infrastructure bill passed in November.

鈥淭here’s funding 鈥� unlike we’ve seen in the 20 years that I’ve been in education,鈥� he said. 鈥淲e have an opportunity here to really lift our field 鈥� and to give our students opportunities that they’ve never had.鈥�

Lead Image: Education Secretary Miguel Cardona testified during a Sept. 30 Senate education committee hearing on school reopening. (Greg Nash / Getty Images)

But bowing to uncertainty sparked by the pandemic, officials will allow one-year changes to the criteria states use to identify those schools. That means the report cards states use to communicate student performance to the public could look quite different.

Get stories like this delivered straight to your inbox. Sign up for 社区黑料 Newsletter

To help measure COVID-19鈥檚 impact, states might also choose to rate schools on how much instructional time students lost or break out chronic absenteeism by whether students were attending school in person or remotely. The department will collect comments on the 31-page document until Jan. 17.

鈥淭his gives a clear signal to the field and to the states that we are restarting accountability,鈥� said Jennifer Bell-Ellwanger, president and CEO of the Data Quality Campaign. 鈥淭his data needs to be reported to families and the community.鈥�

The nonprofit is among the organizations that have been calling for more statewide data on student performance during the pandemic 鈥� even though standardized tests were canceled in 2019-20 and several states saw low turnout for testing last school year. Others say the department, by allowing such a vast array of changes, could leave parents and the public more in the dark about how well schools have performed.

The department is recommending that states and districts update improvement plans to focus on the pandemic鈥檚 effects on the most vulnerable students. States can also give those schools more time to improve by not counting the 2019-20 and 2020-21 school years, and can change the achievement targets they need to hit to be removed from the state鈥檚 lowest-performing list.

鈥淯ncle Sam is saying that not only is it okay to move the goalposts, states can install new goalposts if they want to, too,鈥� said Dale Chu, a senior visiting fellow with the conservative Thomas B. Fordham Institute who helped implement Indiana鈥檚 accountability system.

In addition to the temporary changes, the document encourages states to consider long-term additions, such as adding new indicators of student success that could endure beyond 2022.

鈥楤ehind-the-scenes tinkering鈥�

Under the federal Every Student Succeeds Act, states must test students in reading, math and science and publicly identify their lowest-performing Title I schools and those where groups of students, such as English learners or students with disabilities, consistently underperform. Those schools, which receive extra funds to help students make progress, have up to four years to show improvement or face additional state intervention.

Maria Cammack, deputy superintendent of assessment, accountability, data systems and research at the Oklahoma State Department of Education, said state officials aren鈥檛 talking about adding new measures of school quality for one year, but want to be as transparent as possible about data elements that can supplement its high-stakes accountability system.

鈥淓verybody wants to understand unfinished learning,鈥� she said, adding that it can take a while for districts to report and interpret new information. 鈥淎ny changes enacted for a single year breaks our ability to monitor change in performance in a time where we need to understand it most deeply.鈥�

Bibb Hubbard, president of the nonprofit Learning Heroes, said she appreciated the department鈥檚 expectation that states include families in making decisions about changes to accountability. Parents, she said, rely on state report cards to understand their children鈥檚 progress in school and 鈥渨ant the truth, even if it isn’t good news.鈥� States, she added, should research which measures parents find most meaningful.

Chu added that it could be hard for the public to keep up with 鈥渁ll of the behind-the-scenes tinkering.鈥�

鈥淚f states add, modify [or] remove a bunch of indicators from their state report cards,鈥� he said, 鈥渋t will be extremely difficult, if not impossible, to get an honest accounting of how schools and students have fared.鈥�

A key question for state leaders has been how to calculate whether schools have improved over the past few years in the absence of consecutive years of assessment data. Most states consider test score trends over multiple years as part of their accountability systems.

The guidance suggests states could replace the growth measure with a different indicator 鈥� like achievement gaps 鈥� but experts say such a change could significantly alter which schools are identified for improvement.

Growth is currently 鈥渂y far the best鈥� measure for differentiating between schools, said Cory Koedel, an economics and public policy professor at the University of Missouri鈥揅olumbia and an expert on growth measures. 鈥淚 can鈥檛 even name what a plausible back-up plan would be,鈥� he said.

Chris Janzer, the assistant director of accountability at the Michigan Department of Education, added that there鈥檚 no guarantee state testing will run smoothly this year.

鈥淲e don鈥檛 know what test participation is going to look like this coming spring, especially with Omicron raging now,鈥� he said. 鈥淲ill we have another wave in the spring that causes more school disruptions?鈥�

For 2021 testing, the department waived the requirement that states assess 95 percent of their students. But if schools fall short of that percentage in 2022, it鈥檚 possible they would be identified as low-performing based on participation rates alone, said Janzer, whose state saw 70 percent participation last year.

Oklahoma had an overall participation rate of over 90 percent last spring, Cammack said, but in some districts, only about 30 percent of students took state tests, despite an assessment window that was three weeks longer than normal and included extended hours and Saturday sessions.

鈥楳eet the moment鈥�

Stanford University scholar Linda Darling-Hammond, who serves as president of the California State Board of Education, acknowledged that 2022 probably won鈥檛 be a 鈥渘eat and tidy year鈥� in the realm of testing and accountability.

But she is among those who see the guidance as a way to 鈥渓ay a path toward reauthorization鈥� of ESSA. The department, she said, is sending the message that accountability is important, but that states should also 鈥渕eet the moment鈥� and consider changes that allow more room for other measures of student achievement and school performance.

Bell-Ellwanger, with the Data Quality Campaign, said the guidance presents an opportunity to add criteria that some say is lacking from many state report cards 鈥� such as more data on what students do after high school.

In December, her organization and Chiefs for Change, a network of district leaders, issued a report arguing that K-12 leaders could better prepare students for college and the workplace if data on college enrollment, jobs and other postsecondary trends were more accessible.

鈥淎s states signal that they are moving forward with recovery,鈥� she said, 鈥渦nderstanding college and career pathways and the economic mobility of students is important.鈥�

The department鈥檚 guidance notes that states could also consider adding 鈥渙pportunity to learn鈥� standards 鈥� such as the extent to which students have access to qualified educators and a high-quality curriculum. A recent report from FutureEd, a think tank at Georgetown University, highlighted growing efforts to rate schools on questions of equity, which could range from whether students have access to advanced courses or even if schools have Black and Hispanic mental health providers on staff.

But the report noted that some measures might not be statistically valid and reliable enough for an accountability system that determines consequences for schools.

鈥淭hey need to be predictive,鈥� said Thomas Toch, the director of FutureEd and co-author of the report. 鈥淭hey need to confidently signal how students are likely to perform in school and beyond.鈥�

But he added that just reporting data on some of those goals is still useful for the public even if they aren鈥檛 used to identify schools for accountability. The department鈥檚 guidance takes this 鈥渃autious stance,鈥� he said. 鈥淭ransparency has the power to focus educators鈥� and others鈥� efforts, even when they don鈥檛 face direct consequences for the information that鈥檚 collected.鈥�