Sen. Susan Collins – 社区黑料 America's Education News Source Mon, 14 Jun 2021 21:55:14 +0000 en-US hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=6.7.2 /wp-content/uploads/2022/05/cropped-74_favicon-32x32.png Sen. Susan Collins – 社区黑料 32 32 Senate Leaders Want Answers on CDC-Union Interaction /senate-republican-leaders-seek-answers-on-teachers-unions-influence-over-cdc-school-reopening-guidance/ Thu, 10 Jun 2021 19:33:38 +0000 /?p=573184 Get essential education news and commentary delivered straight to your inbox. Sign up here for 社区黑料鈥檚 daily newsletter.

Leading Republicans on the Senate education committee are calling on the head of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention to provide details about how much the agency interacted with teachers unions and whether she has been completely forthcoming about their involvement in .

North Carolina Sen. Richard Burr, ranking member of the committee, and Sen. Susan Collins of Maine, sent to CDC Director Dr. Rochelle Walensky Thursday with a list of questions about why the guidance was delayed from late January to mid-February. The letter asks Walensky to identify all administration personnel, including political appointees who prepared and reviewed her April 22 letter to the committee, and requests a complete list of 鈥渟takeholders鈥 the CDC contacted, including parents. The senators want to see all documents and communications between the CDC and union employees or members.

鈥淭hat your agency would give teachers鈥 unions privileged access to the agency鈥檚 internal decision-making process on an issue as critical as school re-openings is a betrayal of that trust,鈥 they wrote. 鈥淭hat you then would appear to try to avoid Congressional scrutiny by providing incomplete testimony is deeply troubling.鈥

The letter is the latest example of concerns about political influence over the agency in charge of the nation鈥檚 response to the pandemic. During the Trump administration, Democrats whether senior officials were pressuring the CDC, then led by Dr. Robert Redfield, to downplay the threat of the virus. Now, Republicans are questioning whether President Joe Biden鈥檚 supporters have interfered with efforts to reopen schools.

The CDC did not respond to requests for comment.

On Feb. 27, 社区黑料 filed a request with the CDC seeking information similar to what the senators want 鈥 all documents and communication, such as emails and transcripts of meetings, involving the CDC and any interest groups or individuals consulted in preparing the guidance. The CDC has so far provided internal CDC emails, but not the full list of groups and individuals.

Walensky testified before the committee May 11, saying that the agency sought input from over 50 鈥渃onsumers.鈥 During that hearing, she said the CDC鈥檚 communication with the unions focused on what schools should do if they have immunocompromised teachers.

But obtained through the Freedom of Information Act by Americans for Public Trust and Open Fairfax County Schools, a parents鈥 group in Virginia, show there was extensive email communication between CDC officials and the unions, especially the American Federation of Teachers.

鈥淵our testimony seems 鈥 at a minimum incomplete 鈥 if not inaccurate,鈥 the letter said. 鈥淭he email correspondence makes clear that the involvement of the teachers鈥 unions went well beyond accommodations for high-risk teachers.鈥

AFT, for example, pushed for language saying the agency could change its guidance if a new variant of COVID-19 was detected.

In a Feb. 11 email to Walensky, as well as White House officials, Kelly Trautner, AFT鈥檚 senior director of health issues, suggested: 鈥淚n the event high community transmission results from a new variant of SARS-CoV-2, a new update of these guidelines may be necessary.鈥 She wrote that the union was concerned that even with safety protocols in place, some schools in 鈥渉igh-density, crumbling infrastructure areas鈥 would not be able to safely reopen.

The final guidance reads: 鈥淎s more information becomes available, prevention strategies and school guidance may need to be adjusted to new evidence on risk of transmission and effectiveness of prevention in variants that are circulating in the community.鈥

The Fairfax group said the senators raise important questions and that the public needs to understand why the guidance didn鈥檛 always coincide with the studies and recommendations it received from experts, such as the agency recommending 6 feet of social distancing even when research showed 3 feet was still effective in minimizing transmission. The CDC later reduced its recommendation 3 feet, which the AFT initially opposed.

鈥淭he draconian guidelines, many of which the CDC has subsequently pulled back from, resulted in slower reopenings in parts of the country that treat such guidance as mandatory, a result that was in alignment with the positions being advanced by the AFT and NEA but which caused real harm to the nation’s school children,鈥 the Fairfax group said.

Following the initial release of the emails May 1, AFT spokesman Oriana Korin issued a statement saying the union was in touch with the CDC on behalf of its members, just as it was during the Trump administration.

鈥淎nd while we have at times been concerned about their conclusions 鈥 as we were initially with the change in classroom physical distancing rules 鈥 we respect deeply that the CDC career staff has always taken its responsibility seriously,鈥 she said. 鈥淎nd we appreciate that under Dr. Walensky鈥檚 leadership, the CDC welcomes stakeholder feedback, as opposed to ignoring it.鈥

]]>